In this blog, Anthony McArdle, a learning, training and development officer at the Newcastle Safeguarding Children Partnership, explores how the responses from research he undertook in 2024 have been moved forward by Contextual Safeguarding practices and where there are still challenges to address.
Increasingly, safeguarding practitioners recognise that young people's experiences of harm cannot be understood simply through the decisions they make. Poverty, exploitation, peer dynamics, violence and wider social conditions all shape the choices available to them. Risk is not something that exists solely within young people. It is often produced within the places, relationships and environments that surround them.
This shift in thinking has been central to the development of Contextual Safeguarding and wider Risk Outside The Home (ROTH) approaches. Rather than asking only what a young person is doing, practitioners are increasingly asking what is happening around them.
This blog draws on my dissertation research undertaken in autumn 2024, based on interviews with seven safeguarding practitioners from a range of local authority areas and practice settings. The research took place during a period when many developments now associated with ROTH pathways were still emerging. As such, the findings provide a snapshot of practice during a period of significant change rather than a reflection of current practice across all areas.
What emerged from those interviews was not a lack of contextual thinking – far from it. Practitioners consistently demonstrated a sophisticated understanding of the ways in which neighbourhoods, peer groups and wider social conditions shaped young people's lives. Instead, a different challenge emerged. The practitioners I spoke to often described having more opportunities to understand harmful contexts than to intervene within them.
For young people, this matters because the places and relationships associated with harm are rarely easy to leave behind. The neighbourhood where exploitation occurs may also be where friends live, where school is located or where family connections are rooted. Similarly, peer relationships can be sources of risk as well as of belonging at the same time. Practitioners in this research recognised that young people could not simply walk away from contexts woven into their everyday lives. Understanding these complexities, and responding to them, sits at the heart of contextual practice.
Understanding context was not the problem
Across the interviews, practitioners repeatedly rejected explanations that framed young people as responsible for the harm they experienced. One participant explained that they actively tried to describe risk as something a young person was experiencing rather than choosing, consciously "taking that responsibility away" from the child and focusing attention on the circumstances surrounding them.
Others reflected on the influence of local environments. One practitioner described how growing up in an area characterised by crime, poverty and drug use inevitably shaped what a young person came to view as normal. Another reflected on a young person's limited options, observing that he was making "second-hand choices" because so many decisions had already been constrained by his circumstances.
What struck me most throughout the interviews was not an absence of contextual thinking. The surprise was how often practitioners described understanding contextual harm while feeling less certain about how to influence the contexts producing it. One practitioner reflected:
"I'd be concerned about the actual area that he was living in, but there wouldn't be a lot we could do about that."
Another described how there was only a limited amount of action professionals could take to make contexts safer. The difficulty wasn’t that contextual harm wasn’t identified, it was responding to it.
When contextual understanding outpaces intervention
This tension became particularly visible when practitioners discussed approaches such as safety mapping and peer mapping. Practitioners valued these approaches because they enabled richer conversations about the environments shaping young people's experiences. Safety mapping helped practitioners explore neighbourhoods, routes and locations associated with safety and harm. Discussions about friendships helped practitioners understand belonging, influence, status and protection within peer groups.
However, practitioners often described difficulties acting directly on what these assessments revealed. One practitioner described how, after identifying unsafe places through mapping, some practitioners might later ask: "Why were they there?" This is an understandable question within the context of safety planning. Yet it also revealed something important. Safeguarding responses could sometimes become focused on helping young people navigate risks within existing environments rather than changing those environments themselves.
The same tension emerged in discussions about peer relationships. Practitioners rarely described peer groups as simply 'risky'. They recognised that friendships often provided belonging, protection and support alongside potential sources of harm. Yet direct work with peer groups themselves was less commonly described. "I think we don't do a lot of group work,” one practitioner told me.
Others pointed to practical and organisational barriers that made interventions with peer groups difficult. Consequently, responses often focused on helping young people reflect on relationships, understand peer influence and navigate risks within existing peer networks.
These approaches were clearly intended to support young people rather than blame them, but still most of the practitioners in the research had limited opportunities for further intervention within the contexts young people found themselves in.
A challenge the sector is already responding to
Importantly, this should not be read as a criticism of practitioners or local areas.
The challenge identified in this research is one that the GCCS and the wider Contextual Safeguarding field have repeatedly highlighted over recent years. The question of how to move from contextual assessment to effective intervention has become an increasingly important focus for researchers, practitioners and safeguarding partnerships and, thankfully, significant progress is already underway. Across England, local authorities and safeguarding partnerships have continued to develop Risk Outside The Home pathways, context assessments, context-focused safeguarding conferences and intervention plans for peer groups, schools and neighbourhoods.
Alongside these developments, a range of resources have been created to support contextual responses:
The Context Assessments and Responses Toolkit encourages practitioners to assess and respond directly to the places, peer groups and social environments where harm occurs.
The Context Weighting Framework supports practitioners to consider which contexts should become the primary focus of intervention.
More recently, the Peer Mapping Statement has reinforced the importance of understanding friendships as complex and significant relationships rather than simply identifying risky peers. Related guidance on Identifying Friends and Peers similarly emphasises the importance of recognising friendships as sources of belonging, protection and identity as well as potential sites of harm.
Taken together, these developments reflect a broader movement within safeguarding practice. The focus is increasingly shifting from understanding contexts to changing them.
From insight to action
The practitioners in this research were not struggling to recognise contextual harm. If anything, the interviews demonstrated just how far safeguarding practice has evolved. The professionals involved consistently understood the significance of neighbourhoods, peer relationships and wider social conditions in shaping young people's experiences. Their reflections reveal both the progress that has been made and the challenges that remain.
Creating safety is not simply about helping young people make different choices. It is also about changing the contexts in which those choices are made. Encouragingly, safeguarding systems across England are increasingly moving in this direction. Understanding context is an essential first step, and lasting change depends on whether safeguarding systems are equipped to act on what that understanding reveals. The challenge now is ensuring that contextual assessments lead to meaningful interventions, that safer peer groups follow peer assessments, and that safer places follow place-based assessments.
Young people should not be expected to navigate harmful contexts alone. The task of safeguarding is to work alongside them to make those contexts safer.
Blog published: 12th November 2026